From 1871 to 1911, the Chief of Police in Sault Ste. Marie was appointed by Municipal Council. In 1911, a new by-law established the Board of Commissioners of Police, which assumed responsibility for appointing Chiefs of Police until 1990.
That year, the introduction of Ontario’s Police Services Act brought about a significant shift. Since then, the Sault Ste. Marie Police Services Board has overseen the selection of the Service’s Chief of Police.
Below is a timeline highlighting the individuals who have led the Sault Ste. Marie Police Service throughout its history.
1856 - 1868
Francis J. Hughes
Chief Constable
1868 - 1871
Andrew Hynes
Chief Constable
1871 - 1876
Andrew C. McKay
Reeve of the Village of Sault Ste. Marie, appointed Head Constable

1876 - 1884
John Dawson
Appointed Municipal Constable

1884 - 1885
Thomas Hamill
Appointed Municipal Constable and Nuisance Inspector
1885 - 1887
George Alderson
Appointed Municipal Constable
Feb 1, 1887
Allen Templeton
Appointed Municipal Constable
1888 - 1891
Ira Allen
Appointed Constable

Feb 3, 1891
John Harris
Appointed Constable and Sanitary Officer

1894 - 1895
A. B. McLean
Appointed Policeman

1895 - 1897
D. B. Murray
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned December 31, 1896
1897 - 1900
F. H. Hughes
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned April 30, 1900
1900 - 1911
I. J. Downey
Appointed Chief of Police

1911 - 1921
Ralph C. Vincent
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned April 30, 1921 to become Police Court Clerk

1921 - 1924
John Fortune
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned July 22, 1924
1924 - 1929
Hugh B. Graham
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned October 1, 1929

1929 - 1932
John Borthwick
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned February 23, 1932
1932 - 1942
George Harbottle
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned May 20, 1942

1942 - 1964
Irvin L. Robertson
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned July 31, 1964

1964 - 1978
Frederick R. Clark
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned July 31, 1978

1978 - 1987
Robert T. McEwen
Appointed Chief of Police
Retired March 31, 1987

1987 - 1995
Barry V. King
Appointed Chief of Police
Retired September 30, 1995

1995 - 1996
Robert T. McEwen
Re-appointed Chief of Police
Retired December 1, 1996

1996 - 2014
Robert D. Davies
Appointed Chief of Police
Retired June 30, 2014

2014 - 2018
Robert A. Keetch
Appointed Chief of Police
Retired June 2018

2018 - 2025
Hugh E. Stevenson
Appointed Chief of Police
Resigned March 2025

2025 - Present
Brent Duguay
Appointed Chief of Police
